Pension Lump Sums and the Effect of Changing Interest Rates (2024)

Many defined benefit (DB) plans offer lump sum payouts to their terminated vested participants as a way of “right-sizing” their plan. The ultimate goal is to reduce plan costs and risk. These plans reference a uniform interest rate table issued by the IRS known as the IRS 417(e) rates. There are actually three different rates or “segments”, divided up by time periods through retirement based on one’s life expectancy, that encompass the end lump sum calculation. These rates are issued on a monthly basis.

There is an inverse relationship between these interest rates and the pension lump sum amount a participant would receive. That is, when these interest rates increase, the value of the pension lump sum decreases, and vice versa. With interest rates being so low these past few years, the lump sum option has been an attractive option among retirees.

As someone in or nearing retirement and in the process of making your payout selection, i.e. lump sum verses monthly payments, it is important to consider the following:

Know what your plan is offering.
A DB may incorporate the lump sum option available as part its plan on an ongoing basis or it may offer the option for a limited period of time in a “window”. Know how much time you have to make a decision.

What are the interest rates that will be used for the lump sum calculation?
This may be based on the DB plan year which does not necessarily correspond with a calendar year. Likewise, you must determine which monthly rates the calculation will utilize. Two DB plans we are very familiar with use different months – one uses the July rates, the other December rates. Both apply the designated rate for the entire following plan year.

Are you able to evaluate an A-B comparison with your payments to time your decision?
In other words, are you able to determine the interest rate month and when it takes effect? Does your plan offer a window of time to aid your decision, showing amounts before and after the rate change?

A top notch DB plan, combined with a communicative HR department, should be able to provide you with the pieces necessary to make an informed decision. To navigate through the numbers and understand the impact this decision and the timing of it could have on your retirement outlook, contact Mainstay Capital Management toll-free at 1-866-444-6246.

In the end, it could make a sizeable difference to your retirement nest egg. After all, a change in discount rate of only 5% changes the lump sum payment on $500,000 by $25,000!

Pension Lump Sums and the Effect of Changing Interest Rates (2024)

FAQs

Pension Lump Sums and the Effect of Changing Interest Rates? ›

There is an inverse relationship between these interest rates and the pension lump sum amount a participant would receive. That is, when these interest rates increase, the value of the pension lump sum decreases, and vice versa.

How do interest rates affect my lump sum pension? ›

When interest rates rise, the present value of future pension payments decreases, resulting in a lower lump sum value. Conversely, when interest rates decline, the present value of future pension payments increases, leading to a higher lump sum value.

Will pension lump sums go down in 2024? ›

For calendar year plans with a 1-year stability period, 2024 lump sums for this participant are 6%-17% lower than 2023 lump sums. This is on top of an even larger drop in lump sum values between 2022 and 2023.

Do interest rates affect pension funds? ›

How do rising interest rates affect pensions? Generally, higher interest rates are advantageous to pension planners, as it can mean that money saved in certain kinds of pension pots will see a larger increase in value. Although, it is important to note that this is not the case for all pension products.

What happens to pension liabilities when interest rates rise? ›

As real rates rise (even though in the short term minimum required contributions will increase as bond asset values decline but liabilities remain the same), actual pension liabilities will fall, along with real pension cost, and plans are likely to become overfunded on a current market rate basis.

What are the disadvantages of taking a lump sum pension? ›

What Are the Disadvantages of Taking a Lump Sum on Your Pension? Perhaps the greatest risk of cashing out a pension early is the prospect of running out of money. With life expectancies rising, many retirees face the increasing likelihood that they may outlive their savings, especially if they spend it.

Is it better to take lump sum pension or monthly payments? ›

Monthly payments over time are the format that most people associate with pensions. However, a lump sum payment can, sometimes, be the better option. Depending on what your company offers and what kind of returns you can pursue, you might collect more from your money in the long run by taking it all up front.

Do you have to pay taxes on a lump sum pension payout? ›

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) classifies pension distributions as ordinary income. This means they're taxed at the highest income tax rates. The agency says that mandatory income tax withholding of 20% applies to the majority of lump sum distributions from employer retirement plans.

Can I take a lump sum every year from my pension? ›

Take cash lump sums

You can take your whole pension pot as cash straight away if you want to, no matter what size it is. You can also take smaller sums as cash whenever you need to. 25% of your total pension pot will be tax-free. You'll pay tax on the rest as if it were income.

How do interest rates affect pension transfer value? ›

Interest rates: Changes in interest rates can affect pension transfer values, as they influence the discount rate used in calculating the present value of future pension benefits. Lower interest rates can result in higher transfer values, while higher rates can lead to lower ones.

What happens to retirement accounts when interest rates rise? ›

If you own mutual funds that invest in bonds inside your 401(k) plan, a rise in interest rates will likely lower their share price and net asset value. On the other hand, the income of these funds would likely rise over time as they add new holdings paying higher rates to their portfolios.

What is a good rate of return on a pension? ›

The FCA sets the maximum percentages to be used for each of 2%, 5% and 8% per year. At Penfold, our most popular plan has seen an average yearly growth of 4.6% from inception to September 2023.

How do interest rates affect my pension lump sum? ›

There is an inverse relationship between these interest rates and the pension lump sum amount a participant would receive. That is, when these interest rates increase, the value of the pension lump sum decreases, and vice versa.

Why did my pension go down? ›

If you are invested in a 'lifestyle' fund that's set up for you to buy an annuity when you retire, your pension will be moved from higher risk funds to lower risk funds. This might mean you have less money to draw down than you would if you remained in higher risk funds.

What happens to pensions when inflation is high? ›

Pensions and Inflation

Pension plan benefits are usually tied to the last several years' salary rates earned by the employee. If a period of high inflation hits during the last year or two of a retiree's career, their benefit amounts may come in lower as they are partially based on pre-inflation salary figures.

Is it better to take a lump sum pension or monthly payments? ›

Monthly payments over time are the format that most people associate with pensions. However, a lump sum payment can, sometimes, be the better option. Depending on what your company offers and what kind of returns you can pursue, you might collect more from your money in the long run by taking it all up front.

How do interest rates affect annuity payouts? ›

Interest Rates Still Have an Effect on Annuity Rates

That means that your annuity earns more money during periods of higher interest rates. The more interest you earn, the higher your account value is when you're ready to retire. The higher your annuity's account value, the more income you can count on in retirement.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fr. Dewey Fisher

Last Updated:

Views: 6371

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fr. Dewey Fisher

Birthday: 1993-03-26

Address: 917 Hyun Views, Rogahnmouth, KY 91013-8827

Phone: +5938540192553

Job: Administration Developer

Hobby: Embroidery, Horseback riding, Juggling, Urban exploration, Skiing, Cycling, Handball

Introduction: My name is Fr. Dewey Fisher, I am a powerful, open, faithful, combative, spotless, faithful, fair person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.